—citing concerns over specific contract clauses. As the Bengals prepare for training camp, Stewart’s absence is stirring debate among fans, agents, players, and sports media alike.
Now training at Texas A&M—Shemar Stewart, the highly-touted defensive end and first-round draft pick by the Cincinnati Bengals in the 2025 NFL Draft, is trending across the U.S. for reasons far beyond his explosive play on the field. In a rare and highly publicized rookie holdout, Stewart has yet to sign his rookie dealhis former college—the young star has ignited rumors that he might even return to school rather than sign a deal he considers unfair. The situation is one of the most significant rookie holdouts in recent NFL history and could have long-term implications on how rookie contracts are structured moving forward.
Who Is Shemar Stewart?
Shemar Stewart rose to national attention as a five-star recruit out of Miami, Florida. At 6-foot-5 and nearly 270 pounds, Stewart was a powerhouse defensive end who committed to Texas A&M over several SEC powerhouses. He quickly made an impact for the Aggies, becoming one of the top defensive linemen in college football. His size, athleticism, and pass-rushing ability made him a surefire first-round pick in the 2025 NFL Draft.
The Cincinnati Bengals selected Stewart with the No. 17 overall pick, with expectations that he would bolster an already strong defensive front. But instead of celebrating his transition to the pros, fans are watching an unfolding contract drama that could delay—or even derail—his rookie season.
Lets Start Shopping........
.jpg)
.jpg)
The Contract Controversy: What’s the Issue?
At the center of the dispute is a clause in Stewart’s rookie contract that allows the Bengals to void guaranteed money under certain conditions. According to reports, this language is stricter than what most other first-round picks are asked to sign. Stewart and his agent have pushed back, demanding terms more in line with standard rookie contracts at his draft position.
“This isn’t about greed or entitlement,” one source close to Stewart’s camp said. “It’s about fairness. He just wants what every other first-round pick is getting—nothing more, nothing less.”
The Bengals have not publicly commented on the specifics of the clause, but the fact that the dispute has lingered for over two months suggests that neither side is willing to blink. NFL insiders like Adam Schefter have called the Bengals' approach “unnecessarily aggressive,” especially for a player who is projected to be an immediate contributor.
Training at Texas A&M: A Strategic Statement
Instead of reporting to rookie minicamp and offseason team activities, Stewart was spotted back at Texas A&M’s training facilities this week. Videos surfaced showing him going through intense drills with former teammates and coaches. Some sources within the program have even hinted that he may consider re-enrolling if the deal with the Bengals falls through.
“He’s in peak condition,” said one A&M staff member. “This isn’t just casual offseason training—he’s preparing like he’s going to play this fall.”
While technically Stewart could return to school, it would be a complex process involving eligibility waivers and forfeiture of his current draft slot. Still, the public display of training at his college alma mater is seen by many as a tactical move to pressure the Bengals into meeting his demands.
The Risk of Not Signing
If Stewart does not sign by August 5, the NFL’s rules prevent him from being traded for the entire 2025 season. That means if negotiations break down entirely, the Bengals would lose the ability to get compensation for Stewart—while Stewart himself would risk losing millions in signing bonus money and guaranteed pay.
Another option would be for Stewart to sit out the entire season and re-enter the 2026 NFL Draft. While rare, this route has been taken before—most notably by Bo Jackson in 1986. However, it's a risky move, as it would hurt Stewart’s draft stock and future earning potential. That said, it’s clear Stewart is willing to stand firm on principle, even if it means betting on himself.
Bengals' Position and Public Backlash
While many fans initially supported the Bengals’ desire to be cautious with guaranteed money, public opinion has shifted. Critics argue that the team is jeopardizing a potential star player's rookie season over a clause that most other franchises wouldn’t insist upon. The Bengals have struggled in recent years with internal disagreements and contract negotiations, and this latest standoff only adds to the noise.
Team officials have confirmed that Stewart has been attending virtual meetings and reviewing the defensive playbook, despite not participating in physical practices. Head coach Zac Taylor commented, “We still view Shemar as a key part of our future. We’re hopeful we can get him in camp soon.”
Agent’s Response: “We’re Not Asking for Anything Crazy”
Shemar Stewart’s agent released a public statement last week, saying, “We are not asking for an unusual contract. We’re simply asking for a contract consistent with the slot system and recent precedent.” He pointed out that other players drafted in similar positions, including picks 15–20, have not had void clauses attached to their guaranteed money.
“This kind of clause hasn’t appeared in other contracts of this type in years. It’s a red flag,” the agent added.
What Does This Mean for the NFL?
Stewart’s holdout could set a major precedent for future rookie contracts. If he successfully negotiates a better deal, more first-round picks may begin to push back on team-friendly clauses. On the flip side, if he gives in or is forced to sit out, teams may feel emboldened to push for more restrictive language in the future.
This contract standoff is being closely watched not only by Bengals fans but by players, coaches, and agents across the league. It touches on broader themes of fairness, player rights, and the balance of power in pro sports.
Fan Reaction: Mixed Emotions
Online, fans are divided. Some praise Stewart for standing up for what he believes is fair treatment. Others feel that he should accept the terms and prove himself on the field first. A Reddit thread about the situation quickly gained traction, with thousands of comments debating both sides of the issue.
“If Shemar’s this committed to his principles at 21, imagine what kind of leader he’ll be on defense,” one fan wrote. Another countered, “He hasn’t played a snap yet. This isn’t the time to play hardball.”
Final Thoughts: A Situation to Watch
Shemar Stewart’s ongoing contract holdout is far more than just a rookie dispute—it’s a test of how much power a young NFL player can wield before ever stepping onto the field. As he continues to train at Texas A&M, the message is clear: he won’t be rushed into a deal that compromises his long-term value.
For now, the ball is in the Bengals’ court. Will they blink first, or will Stewart become the first high-profile rookie in years to reject a contract on principle?
Stay with TrueTrendUSA for continued updates on Shemar Stewart’s contract status, Bengals training camp news, and the biggest NFL stories shaping 2025.
0 Comments